The O.C. alum got candid on her past dating life, alleging that ex Chad Michael Murray cheated on her with One Tree Hill co-star Sophia Bush during their romance, which lasted from 2001 to 2002.
“You actually dated a lot of celebs,” Sara Foster told sister Erin on a recent episode of The World’s First Podcast while reading a news article about their former flames, per Entertainment Tonight.
“In it, it said, ‘And he apparently cheated on her with Sophia Bush,'” Sara said. “By the way though, DeuxMoi’s not—they don’t lie. I mean, and that is what happened.”
To which Erin, 41, agreed. “I mean, yeah,” she said. “He definitely did cheat on me with her in, like, a pretty egregious way.”
The Barley Famous star alleged the affair happened while she was living with Chad, adding sarcastically, “Pretty cool.” Chad, 42, went on to tie the knot with Sophia in 2005, though they separated just five months later. Sophia has since expressed that she felt pressured to get married to the Cinderella Story alum, telling Andy Cohen on his Radio Andy Sirius XM show in 2018 that “it was not a thing I actually really wanted to do.”
She recalled that she was just starting her career at the time and was trying to focus on acting.
“I wasn’t looking for a relationship, but one found me and became serious, even though I hadn’t planned to settle down until my 30s,” Sophia wrote in Cosmopolitan in 2017. “But when the person you’re with asks you to marry him, you think: ‘This must be happening because it’s supposed to.'”
The 41-year-old said she will “refuse to let that one relationship define me,” which is why she tried to “avoid discussing it” for a decade.
“The reality is that, yes, it was a massive event in my life,” she continued. “And the trauma of it was amplified by how public it became, which was incredibly foreign and bizarre to a girl who’d been just another college kid 24 months before her life blew up.”
Sophia—who has said she’s no longer “allowed” to talk about Chad publicly—went on to marry entrepreneur Grant Hughes in 2022. However, by August 2023, their relationship was over the hill and done with as she filed for divorce. She’s since started dating soccer star Ashlyn Harris, according to multiple reports, who is in the midst of her own divorce from fellow sports champ Ali Krieger.
Ali cryptically hinted at infidelity in an Instagram post on Oct. 19, writing that she is “preparing for playoffs while in my Beyonce lemonade era.”
In other news – Tupac Shakur murder suspect case postponed for a second time
Duane ‘Keffe D’ Davis, who has been charged with killing rapper Tupac Shakur, appeared shackled in court Thursday before his arraignment was postponed for a second time.
Last month Davis was arrested in connection with the 1996 drive-by killing that resulted in the death of legendary artist Tupac, 27 years after he was killed. A Nevada grand jury indicted him on one count of murder with a deadly weapon and he has been in jail ever since. Read More